Prof. Hernan Huwyler, MBA CPA CAIO · AI GRC Director · Academic Director, IE Law School
Published 17 · Last reviewed 17
- Involve GRC professionals before business decisions are approved, so risks and control gaps can be addressed while changes are still possible.
- Replace subjective control ratings with evidence of effectiveness and quantified exposure against the organization’s capacity to absorb losses.
- Assign executive ownership, deadlines and formal risk acceptance to unresolved issues, with clear escalation and measurable GRC value.
A completed supplier risk questionnaire is often mistaken for evidence of control effectiveness. Procurement has a contract ready for signature, the supplier has submitted its security responses, and every control in the assessment carries a green rating. The risk team is asked to confirm that exposure is acceptable. Yet the ratings say nothing about whether the controls operate as claimed, whether the supporting evidence is reliable, or what financial loss the company could face if the supplier fails.
This is where GRC advisory should begin. A GRC professional must challenge control claims, test the evidence behind them, and quantify the exposure that remains before the organization commits. The assessment should inform decisions on contracts, investments, third-party onboarding, and asset activation while there is still room to change the terms, require remediation, or reject the proposal. Once the commitment is signed, the organization may have limited options beyond documenting the failure and managing its consequences.
My answer to that fork is the point of this article. The advisory role of a GRC professional is to test the control attributes that protect a decision before the decision is made, then to compare the exposure that remains with what the organization can afford to retain, transfer, or price. I recommend doing this ahead of commitments, investments, contracts, third-party onboarding, and asset onboarding, because after signature the only tool left is a finding. This guide is written for risk managers, compliance officers, internal auditors, and control owners who want their opinion to change a decision instead of decorating a file.
The sections follow the order of the work. First, why paper compliance fails and how the Three Lines Model keeps advice separate from ownership. Then why control assessment is an evidence test with pass and reject rules, and where in the decision calendar it belongs. After that, why I stopped relying on residual risk and what I compare instead, followed by a worked example with illustrative numbers. The last sections cover self-assessments, deficiency reporting, formal risk acceptance, and what to do when leadership ignores the advice.





